Outrage over diversity in Super Bowl Ads
It is the year 2014. Slavery was abolished centuries ago and the pain and repercussions forgotten. We have a black President and the color of his skin is barely an afterthought. Foreigners who once fled their country for a chance at a better life in America are welcomed with open arms. Reflections of our culture as a “melting pot” is fairly represented in all facets of media. America doesn’t mean white. America stands for convergence, opportunity and hope.
Oh crap I just woke up. Unfortunately this idealistic dream of what America should be is a dream barely visible in the distant future. The outrage over diversity in last Sunday’s Super Bowl Ads, namely Coca Cola and Cheerios, serve as a hard reminder that we have a long way to go before equality is a reality.
This morning I read an article by The New York Times about the mixed reviews over these two powerhouse brands. Cheerios brought back the blended family of the white mother, black father, and mixed daughter. In this sequel titled “Gracie”, the father explains to his daughter that they are about to have another baby and her humorous reaction. General Mills received a lot of negative backlash last year when they first introduced this family to the screen. In every open forum available, people rattled off angry and racists comments about the commercial. It got so intense that General Mills disabled the comments function on YouTube. General Mills quickly came out with a statement and proudly announced that not only are they going to keep using that family, but they’re going to put them in the Super Bowl,’ ”
Created by Wieden & Kennedy (swoon I just love their work) The Coca Cola spot titled “It’s Beautiful” was a video collage of America. The America that is 13% black, 17% percent Hispanic or Latino, 5% Asian and 2.5% mixed race. In the spot, you hear a woman singing “America the Beautiful” in seven languages as scenes of happiness in a variety of cultures glide across the screen. To me, it was an amazing ad. An ad that evoked emotion which is rare to do. To me, it FINALLY showed the real America. To others, it was an abomination.
Todd Starnes, a Fox News commentator, ignorantly stated on his Twitter “Coca-Cola is the official soft drink of illegals crossing the border” and “Couldn’t make out that song they were singing. I only speak English.”
Glenn Beck, on his radio show commented “Hey, have a Coke and we’ll divide you.”
Allen West, a former Tea Party congressman, posted on his blog “If we cannot be proud enough as a country to sing ‘America the Beautiful’ in English in a commercial during the Super Bowl, by a company as American as they come — doggone we are on the road to perdition. This was a truly disturbing commercial for me, what say you?”
Seriously? People are outraged because the song is in different languages? America doesn’t mean white. America was built and sustained on the backs of immigrants and natives. When will it stop being a shock to see different cultures represented? I have an idea – once the media and advertisers stop being afraid to break the mold. Sure, I can point to hundreds dozens of commercials and TV shows and magazines where ethnicity is represented. However I can point to even more where it is not.
I’ve talked about this before on my blog but I am a huge advocate for diversity training in marketing and advertising. The more we as advertisers push the envelope on diversity, the less commercials like the Cheerios ad and Coca Cola ad will shock people. We need to feature more African-Americans as leading roles in commercials and movies. There should be more representations of Asians Americans as newscasters and in print ads, we should embrace different languages in radio ads and in television shows. The less we are scared about rattling the feathers, the more advanced as a culture we become.
BTW thank you Vanity Fair for finally listening.